Transition Finance · Module 4 of 4
Whose Tonne
Keystone Bank co-financed six transition projects alongside other lenders. Every one of them has really abated a known, verified, public quantity, three thousand six hundred kilotonnes in total, and all of it is already out of the air. Nothing you decide today moves a single tonne. What you decide is how many of those tonnes the bank says it did. The other financiers have already published their claims: two thousand six hundred and fifty kilotonnes, seventy-four per cent of everything that was abated, and at the largest project they have published fifty kilotonnes more than the project ever produced. Nobody is lying. Each of them computed its number from a published methodology, checked it against its own records, and had it signed. Two of them are describing overlapping slices of the same capital because one lent it and the other stood behind it, and neither methodology has a field for what the other reports. There is no ledger you can open and find the error in. Set what the bank claims at each project. The register settles by pro-rata, so where the claims at a project add to more than it abated every claimant is scaled back in proportion, which means claiming more always credits you more and always credits you less per tonne. You pay to verify what you claim, not what settles. The bank promised thirteen hundred kilotonnes of settled abatement three years ago. Its finance share entitles it to fourteen hundred and seventy. The tonnes nobody else has claimed come to a thousand. Those are three different numbers and only one of them is a promise. Where do you claim, and where do you hold back? Entitlement tracks finance and value tracks crowding, and those are different things. Two people in the same meeting argue for integrity from opposite standards: claim what we financed, or claim only what nobody else has. Do they land in the same place, and does either keep the promise? Then the register changes one line and every claimant restates to what it financed. Nothing about the bank moved. Does anything you concluded still hold? This module closes Transition Finance and the Banking domain.