
Supply Chain & Sourcing · Module 1 of 4
The Bullwhip Effect: Why Your Supplier Thinks Your Customers Are Erratic
A supplier rings. Cedarline's purchase orders are impossible to plan against: one month they take four hundred fleeces, the next month almost nothing, and the mill is on overtime one month and idle the next. Every word of it is true. So is the till data, which shows shoppers buying a hundred fleeces a week, every week, all year, with a coefficient of variation of 0.20. Both parties are describing reality accurately and neither can see the other's trace. Then the amplification comes apart, exactly, into two terms that add. The first is the forecast: an order-up-to policy sends the sale plus a correction to the target, and that correction multiplies a wobble by five before it leaves the building. The second is the ordering calendar: three weeks of nothing and one week of four weeks' worth, which is enormous variance manufactured entirely out of the average. On this product the forecast everybody blames is 6.25% of the problem and the monthly purchase-order run, a finance convention nobody thinks of as a forecasting decision, is 93.75%. Three fixes, priced from the same baseline: order weekly is worth $773.31 a week, lengthen the forecast window $22.54, and part-air freight loses $157.46, because it halves a term that was small to begin with. There is a fourth instinct, react faster, and it is worse than doing nothing: halving the forecast window takes the amplification from five to thirteen. The batching term contains no variability at all, which inverts the intuition completely: the steadier the product, the more the calendar dominates. Then the module takes its own answer back three times. It compounds worse than the obvious guess, 5 to 33 to 245 rather than 5 to 25 to 125. Sharing the real end-customer demand collapses that to 25 and does not remove the bullwhip, because the residual is lead time and no data feed shortens a boat. And this arithmetic prices two of the four classic causes: promotions and shortage gaming are named, real, and outside it. Finally the volume doubles and the supplier moves to container pricing, the calendar's share rises to 98.36%, and last quarter's airtight answer becomes the wrong one. Learn the trade, not the answer.
0 of 22 items completed0%~96 min remaining
Material · 22 items