Retail & Distribution · Module 4 of 4
The Coverage Promise: Keep Every Obligated Light Lit — at the Least Cost — and Close Only Where Someone Else Can Serve
The capstone of Retail & Distribution, and the door the first three modules walked past: the community that, no matter how honestly you count, simply doesn't pay, and that you're not free to abandon. You shape Keystone's coverage map across five communities, choosing for each a format, FULL branch, REDUCED (an agent counter, kiosk or mobile van), or CLOSE, to maximise total value = commercial P&L + access value − stranding penalty. Two communities are commercial (a competitor is present, no duty: serve where it pays, close where it doesn't). Three carry an obligation: Keystone is the last provider, so serving captures an access value and closing strands the community for a penalty. The same loss can mean 'close' in a town with competitors and 'how do we keep this cheaply?' on an island with no other bank. Price the promise on both sides: when does an obligated community stay open, and in what format? Keeping access doesn't require a marble branch. Two blanket reflexes both fail, in opposite directions: abandonment (close every loss-maker, the pure-P&L reflex) and gold-plating (keep everything full). The right map is more ruthless than one trap and more generous than the other at the same time. Place the five community pins on the formats against a live total-value meter and a stranded-communities counter; the commercial P&L alone is never the score. Then the obligation moves: a competitor exits one of the towns. Re-draw the map, or hold it? An obligation is a floor on access, not a blank cheque. Module 4 of Retail & Distribution, the close of the course.