NorthRange has ruled its fabric exposure ruinous and sized the hedge; now: WHICH instrument? Devi reaches for the option: 'best of both worlds: cover the downside, keep the upside.' But every instrument is a different payoff shape with its own cost. On the Instrument Bench, read five shapes against one rule: remove the exposure first if you can, then cover the ruinous downside for the most net value. Doing nothing is cheapest and leaves the ruinous spike naked. There's no best instrument; each is the best fit for a situation. Which shape fits?